Where to Catch Broadway Singers Offstage
Insider Spots to Mix and Mingle with Broadway’s Best
Broadway performers don’t just disappear after curtain call. They unwind, experiment, and keep singing in places most people never hear about. If you know where to look, you can catch some of the best voices in the world—up close, unfiltered, and often improvising in a way they never could on stage.
Here’s where to go.
1. Where Broadway Singers Perform Offstage
These are structured venues where Broadway performers regularly put on ticketed shows, cabaret sets, or curated theme nights.
Feinstein’s/54 Below – The Gold Standard for Broadway Cabaret
Tucked beneath the former Studio 54, this intimate supper club is where Broadway’s biggest names perform when they’re off duty. It’s the closest thing to a guaranteed spot for seeing Tony winners outside of a theater. The lineup includes solo concerts, cast reunions, and tribute nights.
What to Know:
Shows sell out fast, especially if a big name is headlining.
Late shows (11:30 pm) often attract performers stopping by after their own curtain call.
Expect a ticket price plus a food/drink minimum.
Birdland (on Mondays) – Where Broadway and Jazz Mix
Monday nights at Birdland mean Jim Caruso’s Cast Party, an open mic where Broadway stars drop in to sing alongside emerging talent. One night, you’ll see a Tony winner belt out a standard; the next, an ensemble member trying out something new.
What to Know:
Mondays are prime time for Broadway appearances.
Seating is first-come, first-served; arrive early for a good spot.
There’s a cover charge and a drink minimum, but the talent level is unmatched.
Green Room 42 – Broadway’s Experimental Playground
Located in YOTEL Times Square, this venue gives Broadway performers a looser, more casual space to try new material. It’s a mix of solo concerts, themed nights, and Broadway Sessions—a series that features cast members from current Broadway shows.
What to Know:
No food or drink minimum, making it more affordable than 54 Below.
Late-night programming sometimes turns into impromptu jam sessions.
Good for catching Broadway understudies and rising stars.
2. Where Broadway Actors Drop In to Perform
These are less structured venues where performers frequently sing but not always on a set schedule.
Club Cumming – Alan Cumming’s Late-Night Playground
Owned by Tony winner Alan Cumming, this East Village spot is an unpredictable mix of cabaret, drag, live music, and theater afterparties. Broadway performers often stop by unannounced, either to sing or just to hang out.
What to Know:
Mondays are best for Broadway sightings.
The space is small and gets packed—expect to stand.
No reservations; just show up and see what happens.
So & So’s – Broadway’s New After-Hours Piano Bar
Opened in 2024, this Hell’s Kitchen lounge has quickly become the place for Broadway performers to drop in after shows. They host Last Call Cabaret, where singers show up post-curtain to sing whatever they feel like.
What to Know:
Live music starts around 9:30 pm, but the best nights are post-10 pm when cast members arrive.
The space is intimate; reservations recommended but not required.
No formal stage—performers casually take the mic, making it feel like a private industry hangout.
3. Where Broadway Actors Socialize
These spots don’t always have live performances, but they’re where Broadway talent goes to drink and decompress.
Bar Centrale – The Post-Show Industry Hangout
An unmarked cocktail lounge in a brownstone on Restaurant Row, Bar Centrale is where Broadway actors, producers, and insiders go to drink and decompress after performances.
What to Know:
It’s a regular stop for Broadway professionals, especially after 10 pm.
Reservations are essential—it’s small and fills up with industry regulars.
Discretion is key. No photos, no interrupting conversations.
Café Carlyle – The Most Elegant Broadway Off-Night
An Upper East Side supper club where Broadway performers occasionally do intimate runs of shows, often featuring jazz-heavy or American Songbook sets. It’s a formal, old-school New York experience.
What to Know:
Reservations required, and expect a high cover charge plus dinner/drinks.
Dress is upscale; this is a place to make an evening of it.
Check the schedule—big names tend to do short, exclusive runs.
4. Where Broadway Actors Sing for Fun
Unlike formal cabaret venues, these are drop-in piano bars and open mics where Broadway singers perform for fun, often mixing with the crowd.
Marie’s Crisis – The Rowdiest Showtune Singalong
A historic piano bar in the West Village where Broadway actors and theater fans belt out showtunes together. It’s loud, packed, and purely for fun.
What to Know:
It’s all singalong—there are no solo performances here.
Broadway actors often show up late at night for post-show fun.
No reservations, no cover—just walk in and start singing.
Don’t Tell Mama – Broadway’s Favorite Piano Bar
A Times Square piano bar where Broadway performers frequently take the mic, either for open-mic nights or spontaneous performances between drinks.
What to Know:
Mondays and late nights are best for Broadway sightings.
No reservations—just find a spot at the bar and see who shows up.
Some nights have structured open-mic formats; others are looser.
Making the Most of It
Monday nights are best. Broadway is dark, which means performers are more likely to be out and about.
Go late. Post-10 pm is when you’ll find cast members unwinding after their own shows.
Blend in. These are performers’ off-hours; respect the space, keep the energy right, and you’ll have a better chance at real interactions.
In Summary
Broadway talent doesn’t disappear when the curtain falls—they just move to different stages. If you want to catch them off-duty, in a more intimate setting, these are the places to go. Pick one, show up, and see what happens. The best moments aren’t planned.
Sing with the Stars produces Broadway-hosted karaoke nights for corporate and global brands in the New York City area. Interested? Register for our next free karaoke night to learn more.